Skip to main content

Five-year climate commitments, thousand-year consequences: scientists call for rethink of global climate policy

News
An international team of scientists argues that the growing scientific understanding of changes to glaciers, ice sheets, sea ice, snow and permafrost is still not sufficiently reflected in climate governance. In their article published today, the scientists point out that the impacts of changes in cryosphere extend far beyond polar and mountain regions and may persist for thousands of years. The article’s lead author, Senior Researcher Letizia Tedesco from the Finnish Environment Institute, says that a key challenge is that some changes in the cryosphere simply cannot be reversed on political or even human timescales.
Landscape of Arctic ice.
The cryosphere, Earth's “frozen sphere”, refers to all water on the Earth's surface that occurs in solid form. It includes glaciers and ice sheets, ice cover on waters, snow and ground frost.. © Don Landwehrle stock.adobe.com

As world leaders gather for 31st Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (COP31) in Antalya, an international team of scientists is warning that climate policy does not yet adequately account for consequences that can unfold over centuries or even millennia. While international climate commitments operate largely on five-year cycles, action omitted today is likely to commit societies to long-lasting changes across the Earth’s frozen regions.

In a new commentary published in Nature Communications, researchers led by scientists from the Finnish Environment Institute, REV Ocean and the British Antarctic Survey argue that the growing scientific understanding of changes to glaciers, ice sheets, sea ice, snow and permafrost is still not sufficiently reflected in climate governance. Although these risks are receiving increasing attention at international climate summits, mechanisms to incorporate them into decisions on emission reductions, climate finance and adaptation remain limited.

The consequences extend far beyond icy regions

The consequences extend far beyond polar and mountain regions. Sea level rise threatens coastal communities. Retreating glaciers affect water, food, safety, and energy security. Thawing permafrost can release additional greenhouse gases. Some of these changes may persist for centuries or millennia.

The catastrophic rock-and-ice collapse and subsequent flooding in Nepal in August 2026 has also highlighted the severe and cascading risks faced by vulnerable mountain communities.

“Cryosphere change does not follow election cycles. A decision made within a few years can shape sea level, water security, ecosystems and infrastructure for centuries. Climate governance needs to become better at seeing—and acting across—those different timescales”, says Letizia Tedesco, lead author, and senior researcher at the Finnish Environment Institute.

“The key challenge is that some cryosphere changes cannot simply be reversed on political or even human timescales. That means climate decisions taken today need to be judged not only by their immediate effects, but also by the risks and commitments they pass on to future generations,” Tedesco continues.

The concerns expressed in the group’s article are reinforced by the recent Overshoot and the Cryosphere: Averting Global Meltdown report, produced by the International Cryosphere Climate Initiative in coordination with the UN Environment Programme, which highlights the lasting consequences of temporarily exceeding 1.5°C of warming.

Science and decision-making need to be more closely connected

Rather than simply calling for greater recognition of these risks, the commentary outlines practical ways to better integrate cryosphere science into existing climate governance. These include establishing a dedicated Cryosphere Dialogue within UN climate negotiations, strengthening long-term monitoring, incorporating indicators of long-term cryosphere commitment into climate assessments, and ensuring that national planning and financial decisions account for consequences extending well beyond current political cycles.

The authors also emphasise that cryosphere governance involves political and economic trade-offs. The costs and benefits of mitigation, adaptation and infrastructure decisions are unevenly distributed across countries and communities. Those most exposed to risks are often not those that have benefited most from the activities driving climate change.

Dr. Josephine Rapp, co-lead author and Science Programme Manager at REV Ocean, says that scientists already know a great deal about how the cryosphere is changing, and increasingly also about the long-term consequences.

“As scientists, we cannot make political decisions, but we can help make sure those decisions are informed by the best available evidence. We need established pathways for the science to feed into planning, funding and accountability, and to remain relevant beyond individual political cycles.”, says Rapp.

“Our research demonstrates major change across all cryosphere elements, destabilising Earth systems that have supported human society over millennia. From the polar ice sheets to mountain glaciers, these frozen environments are critical regulators of sea levels, ocean currents, and global climate stability." says Petra Heil Director of Science at the British Antarctic Survey. 

Link to the Article in Nature Communications:

Tedesco, L., Rapp, J.Z., Heil, P. et al. Governing cryospheric risk beyond political timeframes. Nature Communications 17, 11640 (2026). (nature.com)

Link to ICCI's report:

International Cryosphere Climate Initiative (ICCI). (2026). Overshoot and the Cryosphere: Averting Global Meltdown. The Implications of Temperature Overshoot, Peak and Decline for the Cryosphere International Cryosphere Climate Initiative. (zenodo.org).

The authors will discuss the topic at the COP31 19 Nov.

The paper's lead authors will discuss these findings at the COP31 Cryosphere Pavilion on 19 November at 19:00 (Antalya time), examining whether climate governance mechanisms are equipped to address risks that may persist for centuries. The event will be livestreamed and available on YouTube afterwards: Five-Year Pledges, Thousand-Year Consequences: A COP31 Stress Test of Climate Governance (youtube.com) 

About REV Ocean  

REV Ocean is a philanthropic ocean science organisation dedicated to protecting and restoring the ocean. Through its research vessel, RV REV Ocean, international collaborations and science programme, REV Ocean aims to connect scientific knowledge with practical action for ocean protection. Its priorities include marine protection, capacity development and training, and ocean literacy, bringing together scientists and other stakeholders to help turn knowledge into decisions and solutions that benefit the ocean.

About the British Antarctic Survey

The British Antarctic Survey (BAS) is the UK’s national polar research institute. BAS monitors and observes how the frozen parts of our planet are changing and provides decision makers and the wider world with actionable evidence. BAS has a record of more than 80 years of polar work. Its long-term data collection has led to vital discoveries about the Earth. BAS is the UK’s prime provider for polar infrastructure, experience, and applied knowledge. BAS operates five permanent research stations in and around Antarctica, the UK’s polar research ship RRS Sir David Attenborough and the NERC UK Arctic research station. BAS represents the United Kingdom’s interests in Antarctica, including supporting the UK Foreign Office within the Antarctic Treaty system.
 

Inquiries:

Letizia Tedesco

Senior researcher